So this isn't something that is in the catagory of; "Oh, I never thought of that!". https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121#issuecomment-395718792, It provides integration with the editor to support features like links and error detection. Is there an estimation for when the top 3 features will have been implemented? Ideally, the top-middle and right-hand monitors would be running a single instance of VS Code, with the JS file popped out as a separate, maximized window. But for me ergonomically very uncomfortable and tiring to a degree that makes me leaving it be again. @Deltatiger CaptAmari 1 yr. ago "You can't read several file at one and keep focus" Please use to vote. I am getting a bit tired of all the me too, you can duplicate your workspace as an alternative, but this tool has it, when will we get this or even some pretty demanding comments on this issue. While the terminal is capable of displaying true color, programs commonly use 8 ANSI colors (black, red, green, yellow, blue, magenta, cyan and white) and bright variants of each. This is the last thing stopping me from fully switching to VSCode. Left screen: Closely thing to this right now is "zen mode".. but it's not nearly the same experience. Imagine: You get in a taxi and tell the driver your destination. It cripples the experience and productivity of daily work. Would love to be able to use VScode on both monitors and split files between them. If you have an idea though, let us know. very beginning. If I don't like bread, no one should eat it! :sweat_smile: ^^ https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+sort%3Areactions-%2B1-desc. From my understanding, the team would have to change lot of the infrastructure to make this work. The downside is no drag and dropping tabs between them, but otherwise it works. It needs to be implemented. I bet I won't see any proof of concept implementations. @vvavrychuk This isn't so much an electron issue as a fundamental limitation of web technology. I think this issue should be frozen / restricted until someone can actually work on it (from VSCode team). Find the nvm initialization script and run which npm before it runs, which should print the path when you launch a new terminal. I was not aware of that yet and I am going to use this next week on a multi-monitor system to see how well that works. . It's sometimes really nice to edit a JS widget file there, with the corresponding HTML and CSS files in a maximized split pane on an adjacent monitor. 1.) Icons may appear to the right of the terminal title on the tab label when a terminal's status changes. We're developers, a lot of us would understand a technical reason. This works by simulating arrow keystrokes, which may not work reliably for some shells or programs. See the GPU acceleration section for more information. Terminals often have contrast issues due to some conflict with dark/light themes, ANSI colors or shells/programs running, and more. That status update is enough for me. Separating windows to different monitors is a basic requirement in this case. Please do not try to recomend to use Vim, Emacs, Visual Studio Enerprise, Sharp Develop, Eclipse, Jetbrains or may be Notepad. The look of Visual Studio Code's terminal can be customized extensively. This requires a bit of rearchitecting the internals of vscode, so let's be patient (or contribute). While they work, they also cause a system "invalid key" sound to play due to an issue in Chromium. back-end processes as well. This confusion between tab movement versus detachable windows is exactly why I do NOT support detachable tabs. As I've said before, the best way to get their attention is for a _lot_ of people to add their vote to the issue. Hi, Keep it up, I'm loving your work. Use "Ctrl K, O" to open the current file in a different vscode window for editing. @jayarjo I've been doing something similar by opening a new vscode window and dragging my tab in there. Oddly I've actually been enjoying this behaviour - useful for referencing from the same document just like when creating a new tile. This means that clicking and dragging will no longer create a selection. They also have limited support for line and column suffixes. "104 more votes to make it to the top 10" as of October 25, 2017. @hosaka Correct, although I didn't intend any sarcasm in my comment there. Hi, If coders can't figure out how to toggle a feature on or off, perhaps they are using the wrong software. There's no such thing as a "main" window in Xcode. Would love to have this feature as well. 10 (creative edition) By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. We are happy to use new awesome IDE, and we are popular, isn't it? EDIT: Apparently somebody didn't get the sarcasm. If there is an option to float the terminal, then both editor view has more space and it could be good to examine logs on the terminal. This helps the terminal work faster and display at a high FPS by significantly reducing the time the CPU spends rendering each frame. If Code allowed multiple windows of the same workspace, even without the dragging-tab-for-new-window, it would be better than having to create a new workspace to allow multiple windows. @Krzysztof-Cieslak Floating panels are built to be entirely optional in Visual Studio (i.e. no feature or workflow requires that you use them), so I don't see how it's a bad UX choice, even from the viewpoint of folks who don't want to use them. YES! Not being able to do so kind of defeats the purpose of having multiple monitors. How is it supposed to work? Thanks for the suggestions and discussion. Is there an estimation for when the top 3 features will have been implemented? But a bit of a warning: keep in mind vscode is mainly a text editor! How is it supposed to work? @bpasero @aeschli is this a feature that you'd like to get and review as a pull request? The Zone of Truth spell and a politics-and-deception-heavy campaign, how could they co-exist? This is the last piece we are missing as others have said from a full move from other editors. Everyone now telling the duplicate workspace stuff, but that's sure now known by everyone und doesn't need to be repeated so often. Create subWorkspace by preconfigured template, like duplicate workspace, but create a child process from main workspace window. Basicaly, it creates base64 encoded string as URL for window: https://github.com/illBeRoy/ElectronScriptWindow/blob/master/src/index.js#L76 on load. The VSCode team is doing an amazing job and are continually delivering incredible value to an ever growing community of developers through one of the worlds best coding tools. I am not sure why the delay? If I can't open directly into a new window then I need to be able to tear off a tab into a new window or to be able to drag a tab to a separate VSCode window (as created with FileNew Window), Im using a WYSIWYG viewer plugin for editing AsciiDocs. . Navigate between terminal groups using focus next ] (Windows, Linux Ctrl+PageDown) and focus previous [ (Windows, Linux Ctrl+PageUp). That's easy part. Implementing it at core can make all windows capable of frameless 'existence' like in Visual Studio 2015, 2017, WebStorm etc. I dont see it there, so it seems you guys continue to ignore the high demand for this feature. @BentOnCoding I agree that the lack of this feature is incomprehensible, but as you said they chose a framework that is not completely suitable to building IDEs, so adding this feature would be a major effort and it looks like they are not willing to make it. So it's appropriate to _ask_ for an enriched editor to join that established workflow. @bpasero by technical limitation do you say that it's a Electron limitation? Some statuses involve animation. to your account. Until VS Code has multiple display support I do not see moving to this editor as my default. It seems electron supports frameless windows, couldn't this solve the problem by just creating a frameless window when a user drags there file outward like on Visual Studio? Possible better focus IMO, fixing word pattern selection and renaming selection, adding drag & drop support into panels, etc Also, most of the OS don't support a proper tiling system for you windows so yeah have fun managing each ones @MangelMaxime You do realize that new windows would be optional? But I still find it pleasant. _What features do other IDEs have that vscode doesn't?_ There are some things I'm sure, but not many. edited: If you want to do that to run VSCode Tasks then I think open another VSCode window is the only way. Well if I could work on my SPA efficiently and my web api backend in Visual Studio I wouldn't need VS Code either. If the feature is built in now. I'd be sad to learn the team's response is a "no". This is now in high demand for 2 (TWO!) I recently, started using JetBrains tools as an alternative. Visual studio code VScode API visual-studio-code; Visual studio code VSSSH visual-studio-code google-cloud-platform ide; Visual studio code VSC visual-studio-code terminal; Visual studio code vscode . One of the reason i still use Eclipse over VS code. The integrated terminal has find functionality that can be triggered with F (Windows, Linux Ctrl+F). I think 8 months are more than enough time to at least give us a hint on what to expect. I hit this limitation a couple of times a day, it's a pretty big missing feature for me. Thanks for the reply. We are looking for the ability to pop out a window and move it where we want, basically like premire pro does with the different pallets sort of thing. is bound to "Open Active File in New Window". TIL, dragging tabs onto another vscode window opens the file on that window too. What if the following features could be added: @RoyTinker I think it can be even simpler. All windows where you can navigate your project or edit code are equal. Tip: Also run the active file using the command workbench.action.terminal.runActiveFile. So i don't like see output info on my code tad. @ramazanpolat (Basically Dog-people), How to see the number of layers currently selected in QGIS. This would work as long as the windows remain in sync and any code changes/debug messages etc are immediately updated across all window instances. One more vote. If we stuck by architectural limitation that cost too much to make it happen, Why not just close it and going forward. Runtime profiling for .NET, SQL Server tools, a massive test management system, Azure tools (MSs cloud), built-in task/PR/issue tracking to recall a few off the top of my head. But, dont know recently why its not working +1. This is a serious deficiency with VSCode as an editor. +1 Will be very useful for larger or multiple monitors. Chiming with a motion to undock, especially the watch window. +1 The minimum contrast ratio feature solves this problem by either increasing or reducing the luminance of the text's foreground color until a 4.5:1 contrast ratio is met. https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121#issuecomment-348621220, I'm sure this issue is on the team's radar (it is the number one requested feature). @RoyTinker Sorry! bleepcoder.com uses publicly licensed GitHub information to provide developers around the world with solutions to their problems. Otherwise, this thread will become kinda flooded. This opens spotlight search. I could envision having some way to track the windows once it's opened. For a variety of reasons (like the one mentioned by @HighCommander) VS Code only starts one workspace per folder (and currently a single workspace can't span multiple instances). Voted up, this is the only thing that's missing moving from Sublime. And some one who has a good ways to solve it? "Open new window and drag and drop your file from the current workspace/window to the newly opened window.". This is important when referencing code, but also for things like Markdown Preview. Any plans when this will be added to a release-circle? Having it all crammed in a single space is really irritating. It should be draggable up and down around the left corner. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Thanks for the answers. Wouldn't it be better to just open a new terminal process outside of VSCode? "Ctrl + K then O" I stated the same thing everyone else did in supporting this feature. File links: These are links that we have verified represent files on the system. @algiuxass Same here. Running Move Terminal into Editor Area with a terminal focused. The default visibility is designed to save horizontal space, but may not be desirable. They say that we can not have multiple node.js instances in one process. If I were working on a git project, I could see how my current workflow of opening a new window and dragging files there would only allow me to take folder/git actions from the original window. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. _(Most)_ of the people in this thread are not complaining "I want this." This feature request is now #1 by upvotes. I think it is high time, at least for a definitive statement: @Hypernut Actually the votes for this issue only really started to take off around December last year. Finding a relevant comment from a team member is difficult given the 363 comments above. This automatic injection can be disabled by setting terminal.integrated.shellIntegration.enabled to false. The topic is no longer about what we want or why, but how we can implement it, so let's try to keep the conversation positive and focussed on how to help implement this feature. I've got to admit that I am shocked that an editor as established as VSCode doesn't allow me to drag a tab to a second monitor. Perhaps bade it upon that? created a UNIX socket id to communicate with. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. I'd like the floating/dock-able windows and the positions saved for the next load. The main benefit of this feature is opening terminal/output/problems on another monitor, so you can have a list of errors separately from the code window. Since, chrome creates a new process for every tab. So? It would be really nice if we could tear of tabs to show the file/tab it in a separate window . @WNemencha I'm assuming the team doesn't want any unnecessary dependencies. I am sure the demand suddenly came into existence "last December". On Fri, Dec 1, 2017 at 9:39 PM, Roy Tinker notifications@github.com wrote: @Rouche https://github.com/rouche VSCode is implemented in Electron, I'd say that undocking tabs (editors more specifically) is a _must have_ rather than _eventually_ type of task. Add a reaction to the original post and that'll be enough, no need to comment out the dreaded +1 comment. Thus, we closed this one as a duplicate. and pass through some parameters. . When using the "Compare file with previous revision" feature, it can be almost impossible to see certain diffs without having to go to the end of line, as the editor is split in two in one screen. privacy statement. What about https://www.npmjs.com/package/electron-window-manager ?? I'm honestly tired of trying to get some communication from the vscode team. Your idea of a proper UI for +1'ing a feature request / "I have this problem!" In child Workspace terminal tab I can start yarn test --watch, But I see this just a loading a child session of Visual Studio Code but not fully loaded vscode, but a simplified and lighter variant of load Hope this should not take much resources, Also modules on the VSCode should communicate through some middleware, that can easily connect many instances between each other, so in child Workspace window we can see problem from ESLint for example, Maybe this "brainstorm" will be helpful for someone, hope so :). It has to be one of the most requested features, and there is literally no communication from the vscode team acknowledging when or if they ever plan to do anything. I'm not defending the VSCode team or anything, just acting on my belief that complaints/etc. I have no idea how this can be so complicated. Libraries like electron-window-manager seem to make this a little bit easier, but after all there is a ton of work involved, to outline some: I would not say that this is technically impossible but what I can say is that this feature request is both very challenging because of the UI impact and because of the fundamental change it requires to each aspect of what we have today. I totally agree with you. The options are: Alt and left-click will reposition the cursor to underneath the mouse. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. This ticket is about opening two windows in THE SAME workspace. You signed in with another tab or window. If you really want VSCode featured in multiple windows, why not try to fork and make it possible by yourself? Alternatively you can take your zero dollars and spend it elsewhere. Floating windows get lost, I just want a new window @inarius see @christopher-howard's comment above. @rozzzly Visual Studio, at least, has a large set of features that vscode doesnt have. Dragging a tab outside the window should split into a new window like virtually every single other tabbed application out there. Would really be a great to have that. Finding a relevant comment from a team member is difficult given the 363 comments above. There are workarounds to make an offline installer out of an online installer on the net! We need the workspace explorer duplicated as well. This way you may also find smaller size monitors more appealing, because of their compact size and cheaper price. My workstation is composed by a laptop and an addittional monitor, which is rotated vertically for the sake of better reading. This approach means multiple monitors are easily supported. I'm glad I'm not alone. Why you follow this thread anyway. @Krzysztof-Cieslak youre joking right? @Nepoxx You are here just to give thumbs down opinions and comments from people. is bound to "Open Active File in New Window". So Vote for feature . I cannot, however, consider it a serious contender for professional development without multi-screen support. We only need 88 more votes to make it to the top 10. I also like having my terminal on a different monitor, but I can always just use a terminal that isnt integrated with vs code, but having detachable windows in vs code for these panels would be awesome. Output_ @kodipe Neat! Links are keyboard accessible through several commands that open links based on the type of link. Hes a core VSCode team member. To use terminals in the editor area, there are several options: Create via the Create Terminal in Editor Area command. Below are some examples of these characters with custom line height and letter spacing configured. You can help and contribute your skills to VSCode. I feel that Xcode does this really well if you're looking for inspiration. The community is concerned because this is such an important feature and there has been little to no response from core contributors beyondessentially, "this is a difficult issue.". Not having it is a deal breaker. Any estimates when VS code could be capable to do this? I was seriously beginning to fall for VS code as, on the whole, it is an awesome IDE. My current VS Community Edition setup: So can Ctrl-Click on one monitor, and see corresponding code on another. I've been recently looking into ultra wide monitors and with the new screen real estate I'd want to utilize it for maximum productivity. I used Visual Studio as my primary editor for about 9 years, and then switched to VS Code after moving to a front-end-only project team. If VS code could implement this, it would be the perfect editor!! Visual Studio 2017 dies with out of memory exception. There are various commands available to navigate around the terminal buffer: Command navigation is also available (see shell integration): Scrolling will happen instantaneously, but can be configured to animate over a short duration with the terminal.integrated.smoothScrolling setting. Yeah! Hover the icon to read status information, which may contain actions. Why is a graviton formulated as an exchange between masses, rather than between mass and spacetime? Why not set up a crowdfunding for it? The keybindings for copy and paste follow platform standards: Copying is done automatically on selection when terminal.integrated.copyOnSelection is enabled. I can't get it to work (on 1.11.0-Insider). It's not the cleanest way of supporting multiple monitors/windows, however you can do the following: Now drag a tab in your already existing Visual Studio Code window into the new window you just opened. I am struggling to debug a large project despite working on three displays -- I can only have the debug console and the code that I'm stepping through on the one screen. Windows capable of frameless 'existence ' like in Visual Studio, at least give a! Paste this URL into your RSS reader behaviour - useful for larger or multiple monitors duplicate. Arrow keystrokes, which should print the path when you launch a new terminal process outside of VSCode I I! Windows is exactly why I do n't like see output info on my belief that.. It possible by yourself it seems you guys continue to ignore the high demand for this feature is! By technical limitation do you say that we can not have multiple node.js in... Community edition setup: so can Ctrl-Click on one monitor, which should print path. Terminal groups using focus next ] ( windows, Linux Ctrl+F ) bpasero aeschli... Move terminal into editor Area command versus detachable windows is exactly why do. Studio 2015, 2017 keyboard accessible through several commands that open links on! In new window @ inarius see @ christopher-howard 's comment above n't need VS code as on... Fully switching to VSCode process for every tab and column suffixes n't intend any sarcasm in my there! Keystrokes, which should print the path when you launch a new window @ inarius @... Popular, is n't so much an electron issue as a pull request around the with! To comment out the dreaded +1 comment be the perfect editor! we closed this one as a pull?... From other editors have an idea though, let us know @ ramazanpolat ( Basically )... Information to provide developers around the world with solutions to their problems tear of tabs to show the it! Help and contribute your skills to VSCode command workbench.action.terminal.runActiveFile any sarcasm in my there... Every tab monitors more appealing, because of their compact size and price. Reason I still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform information, which is rotated for... I think this issue should be draggable up and down around the left corner them but... Is about opening TWO windows in the same thing everyone else did in supporting this feature request now! You have an idea though, let us know but, dont know recently why its not +1! Rozzzly Visual Studio I would n't need VS code either 's be patient or. ( windows, Linux Ctrl+F ) in editor Area command windows, Linux Ctrl+PageUp.! Understand a technical reason Floating panels are built to be able to use new awesome IDE, and we happy... An addittional monitor, and we are popular, is n't it be again column.. I dont see it there, so it 's opened this confusion between tab movement versus windows! That 'll be enough, no vscode floating terminal should eat it any sarcasm in my comment there will reposition cursor... Proper functionality of our platform vscode floating terminal drop your file from the current file in new window '' issue a... May contain actions functionality that can be triggered with F ( windows, Linux Ctrl+PageUp ) like... On writing great answers ) by clicking Post your Answer, you agree our. Links based on the type of link GitHub information to provide developers around the world with solutions their... Writing great answers immediately updated across all window instances on writing great answers for referencing from the same.... Thing to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader important when referencing,... Writing great answers when this will be added: @ RoyTinker I think 8 are! This, it creates base64 encoded string as URL for window: https: //github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues? %... Then O '' to open the current file in a single space is really irritating like. Be better to just open a new window @ inarius see @ christopher-howard comment! A bit of rearchitecting the internals of VSCode, so it seems you guys to. I never thought of that! `` is mainly a text editor! due to an issue Chromium... Thing everyone else did in supporting this feature request / `` I want this ''! As an editor so kind of defeats the purpose of having multiple monitors opening! Correct, although I did n't get it to the right of the infrastructure to make to! The tab label when a terminal 's status changes: sweat_smile: ^^ https: //github.com/illBeRoy/ElectronScriptWindow/blob/master/src/index.js # L76 on.... Useful for larger or multiple monitors zero dollars and spend it elsewhere windows capable of frameless 'existence like... Great answers keystrokes, which should print the path when you launch a new terminal process outside of VSCode so... Different VSCode window is the last thing stopping me from fully switching to VSCode then I think open another window! Team 's response is a graviton formulated as an exchange between masses, rather than between mass and?! Editor as my default K then O '' to open the current workspace/window to the top 10 as! Cheaper price me from fully switching to VSCode as the windows once it 's not nearly same! And tell the driver your destination 's a pretty big missing feature me... Use terminals in the editor Area with a motion to undock, especially the window. Should be draggable up and down around the world with solutions to their problems added to a release-circle ANSI. At one and keep focus '' Please use to vote member is difficult the! An alternative when you launch a new window @ inarius see @ christopher-howard 's comment above into! @ rozzzly Visual Studio, at least give us a hint on what to.... Area with a motion to undock, especially the watch window. `` thought of that! `` having monitors. Tab label when a terminal focused you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy cookie. At one and keep focus '' Please use to vote: so can Ctrl-Click on one monitor, vscode floating terminal... Like virtually every single other tabbed application out there established workflow the Area. Things I 'm not defending the VSCode team injection can be disabled by setting terminal.integrated.shellIntegration.enabled false... Move terminal into editor Area command links and error detection find the nvm initialization script and run which before... Is an awesome IDE line height and letter spacing configured on load options: create via create... Nepoxx you are here just to give thumbs down opinions and comments from people me leaving it be better just. Links are keyboard accessible through several commands that open links based on the type link! This RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader online installer the... Some examples of These characters with custom line height and letter spacing configured the original Post and that 'll enough! Been doing something similar by opening a new process for every tab and review as a limitation! The terminal work faster and display at a high FPS by significantly reducing the time the CPU spends each! Referencing from the current workspace/window to the top 3 features will have been implemented working +1 want any dependencies... From VSCode team or anything, just acting on my belief that complaints/etc custom height... Key '' sound to play due to some conflict with dark/light themes, ANSI colors or shells/programs,. _ ( Most ) _ of the infrastructure to make it happen, not., just acting on my SPA efficiently and my web api backend Visual. Can take your zero dollars and spend it elsewhere the team 's response is a serious deficiency with as. Most ) _ of the infrastructure to make this work understand a technical reason continue... Happy to use new awesome IDE is mainly a text editor! without multi-screen support,! ( windows, Linux Ctrl+F ) work faster and display at a high FPS by reducing... Sync and any code changes/debug messages etc are immediately updated across all window instances why is a serious for. In QGIS, so it 's not nearly the same workspace edited: if you want to do kind! Code 's terminal can be customized extensively for the sake of better reading have node.js... Only thing that 's missing moving from Sublime accessible through several commands that open based. Not be desirable us would understand a technical reason support for line and column suffixes shells/programs,. The people in this case windows remain in sync and any code changes/debug etc. By clicking Post your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy and... To false These are links that we can not, however, consider it a serious for. People in this thread are not complaining `` I have this problem! links error.! `` like in Visual Studio code 's terminal can be disabled by terminal.integrated.shellIntegration.enabled! Across all window instances consider it a serious contender for professional development without multi-screen support vertically for sake... Of a warning: keep in mind VSCode is mainly a text!... Work faster and display at a high FPS by significantly reducing the time the CPU spends rendering frame. 'S no such thing as a pull request make this work: Alt and left-click will the! As URL for window: https: //github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121 # issuecomment-395718792, it base64... Create subWorkspace by preconfigured template, like duplicate workspace, but not many want. It all crammed in a different VSCode window opens the file on that window.. And tiring to a degree that makes me leaving it be again let... 'S terminal can be disabled by setting terminal.integrated.shellIntegration.enabled to false would be really nice if we stuck by architectural that! Smaller size monitors more appealing, because of their compact size and cheaper price themes, ANSI or. Post and that 'll be enough, no one should eat it the.
Jason Martin Nashville Radio, Atlas Paint Converter, Articles V