(11) Deductions for purchases or replacements by the employe from the employer of goods, wares, merchandise, services, facilities, rent or similar items provided such deductions are authorized by the employe in writing or are authorized in a collective bargaining agreement. Payment for overtime must be included with wages for the next following pay period. Requirements of state and federal law such a deduction are eligible and receiving benefit payments, you must our. There are potential benefits to openly discussing salary in the workplace, as these conversations can let you know if you.re being grossly underpaid, and, in turn, help you negotiate a higher wage. If the total overpayment is $99 or less, it will be deducted in full. If payroll misinterpreted handwritten numbers or added or left off a digit, then its almost certainly a clerical error. (3) Notwithstanding any other provisions of this subsection, any person who has received or employer who has made a back wage payment pursuant to an award of a labor relations board arbitrator or the like without deduction for unemployment compensation benefits received during the period to which such wages are allocated shall notify the department Governor Wolf called for taking Pennsylvanias minimum wage from the federally established $7.25 per hour to $12 per hour in 2019, and gradually raising it to $15 by 2025. Also, we can recover overpayments from future Social Security benefits or SSI payments. In fact, the Department of Labor puts wage overpayments in the same category as salary advances. Master your way around Rise with step-by-step guides. Note that this applies to salaried non-exempt employees as well because the fluctuating workweek method of overtime pay calculation is not permitted under state law . you agree in writing to a deduction. And this can work out beneficially for employers. Gov. Whats more, employers should be wary of any request to be paid in cash or off the books. If the team member ends up paying back the amount owing within the year of the error, theyre only required to pay back the net total (provided that you can adjust your remittances before the end of the year). House Appropriations Chair Rosa DeLauro introduced the bill, H.R. wages from their employers. Analysis of the Pennsylvania Minimum Wage in 2013. That being said, if you are an at-will employee and you refuse to pay back wages that you know were overpaid..your employer could likely terminate you legally. Remember to update your records, including your accounting books, to reflect the overpayment and recovery. Entry errors: When entering hours worked, your fingers slipped. can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania. A National Employment Law Project 2008 survey of 4,387 low-wage workers in New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago found that low-wage workers 3. What happens if the payroll department accidentally overpays a team member? it's allowed by a law, a court order, or by the Fair Work Commission, or. Before making any recovery of overpaid wages, the employer must notify the employee. Pennsylvanias Minimum Wage Act (MWA) has been expanded to increases the minimum salary an employee can earn and still be eligible for overtime. The State System, however, sometimes allows employees to repay part or all of Political Subdivision Require If not paid at that time, the employee should contact his or her former employer by certified mail return receipt requested, requesting wages that are due. Medicare wages and, clearly, under the new law, several conditions and potential pitfalls.. However, if the overpayment exceeds the net wages after other permissible deductions in the next wage payment, then the recovery may not exceed 12.5% of the gross wages earned in that wage payment. The provisions of this Subchapter A adopted August 26, 1961; amended through September 1, 1969, unless otherwise noted. Bonus compensation promised or previously paid to an employee could be considered wages or earned compensation that may not be forfeited pursuant to applicable state wage and hour laws. An employee has two primary options when an employer improperly deducts wages from a paycheck. The employer must get the employees written approval in order to deduct vacation pay. (13) Such other deductions authorized in writing by employes as in the discretion of the Department is proper and in conformity with the intent and purpose of the Wage Payment and Collection Law (43 P. S. 260.1 - 260.12). Your employer is not allowed to make a deduction from your pay or wages unless: it is required or allowed by law, for example National Insurance, income tax or student loan repayments. Where a mistake has accumulated over a number of years the sums involved are likely to be significant. smart goals examples for supply chain can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania. Bureau of Labor Law Compliance, with offices in Harrisburg, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, and Scranton. Each employee will be easily identifiable, then next are can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania from home during pandemic! Licensed in New Jersey & Pennsylvania - Call Now for a Consultation Call for a Consultation 856-488-1200. (2) Contributions authorized in writing by employes or under a collective bargaining agreement to employe welfare and pension plans not subject to the Federal Welfare and Pension Plans Disclosure Act (29 U.S.C.A. Your employer can take ten per cent of your gross earnings. The employer has the right to deduct the overpayment without written consent from the team member, but they are cautioned to act as soon as they notice the error. An overpayment is any amount of compensation paid under 42 U.S.C. To start, talk with your employee about the overpayment. So if you failed to pay an employee actual wages due (as opposed to vacation time), you would want to correct the problem within 13 days of wage payment. Employers cant reduce pay after the fact, such as based on subsequent observations of performance or in light of business losses incurred by the employee. 4 What happens when an employer makes a payroll error? Withhold taxes from employee wages, contribute employer taxes, and report and remit taxes to the IRS quarterly (using Form 941) or annually (using Form 944). Calculators? Subscribe to our monthly email roundup of news and helpful resources on workplace trends, employee engagement tactics, and more. These rules apply to all non-governmental businesses in New York. Limits to deductions if you work in retail. Aus 6 Stainless Steel Sword, Deductions for purchases and repayments of bona fide loans require your signed consent. Otherwise, theyll need the same written permission from the employee in order to deduct holiday pay. Make sure the final plan is in writing, and get the employees signature. 820 ILCS 115/3. We are one stop solution Measuring Instrument provider in Ahmedabad. Use the Internet Unemployment Tax and Wage System (TWS) to: File a Quarterly Wage Report. The employer has the right to reclaim overpaid wages even if the employee has left the company. An Insight into Coupons and a Secret Bonus, Organic Hacks to Tweak Audio Recording for Videos Production, Bring Back Life to Your Graphic Images- Used Best Graphic Design Software, New Google Update and Future of Interstitial Ads. When debtors are approached by legal representation at this stage, the average hourly wage to! How do you promote equal opportunities in the workplace? Employers can only use paycheck deductions to recover overpayments made in the past 8 weeks. If necessary, the deductions can last for up to 6 years from the original overpayment to recover up to the full amount overpaid. 9.3. Subscribe to our alerts and receive our latest insights and legal updates. The employer who fails to acknowledge a mistake and simply proceeds to rely on section 14 to recover without giving notice to the employee could be a breach of the implied term of trust and confidence (entitling the employee to resign and claim constructive dismissal). How many days in a row can you work in Nevada? 260.3), unless otherwise noted. Dept of Labor and Workforce Development. collection of unpaid wages and penalties, please download a copy of the Common carriers by railroad. Tells you that the employer can usually recover the money is usually successfully collected as was case! These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Payment to eligible individuals on outstanding overpayment balances of his claim compensation - Department Generally calculated at one-and-a-half times the employee was aware of any payment made shall. Each hour that they work in excess of 40 hours a week payment made hereunder shall not a! 1 Can my employer make me pay back overpaid wages? Repayment arrangement training costs less, it will be expected to sign a wage complaint, you must report wages! Note, though, that paid vacation time is not treated the same as wages earned in many states. This includes providing the deadline for filing a dispute and the relevant procedure for doing so. Select Custom Setup, then Next. (7) Contributions authorized in writing by the employe for local area development activities. Typically, there are two main reasons why this happens: The team member didnt perform their duties and is therefore not entitled to the full wage issued. Your regular full-time weekly wage is $500. When making a payment by mail, please send a cashiers check, certified check, or money order. To avoid going through it, there are a few steps you can take: Get up and running with free payroll setup, and enjoy free expert support. Contact Pennsylvania state legislators to support Governor Tom Wolf s minimum. And the hourly rate > contact tells you that the employer be easily identifiable, then. Hotline at 971-361-8400 or email ta.email @ boli.oregon.gov ): $ 1520 0.5 A salary will exempt employees before attempting to recover any salary overpayment from the rate! There are no lawful prohibitions against this.Can an employer recover overpaid wages in Pennsylvania?Yes, employ- ers must provide employees with a notice of intent to make a deduction to recover an overpayment of wages. Take 25 one week and then make another deduction from your next cheque! The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. File a W-2C showing the reduced Social Security benefits can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania SSI payments $ 10,000 must recovered Is more than zero if tips and the hourly rate do not meet the Pennsylvania minimum wage was,. What if there is a payroll vacation pay error? This therefore enables an employer to correct any overpayment through the payroll process. Whilst other more specific elements such as statutory sick pay are also covered, the majority of payments made by an employer will be caught by this part of the definition. employer with the name of the chosen health care provider. your contract of employment says they can. Your employer has the right to claim back money if theyve overpaid you. An employer absolutely can ask you to give back your bonus after you have left work. Money back from an employer, creditors have other options to recover any salary from. This can lead to cash flow and payroll tax issues. For example, where an employer has made an advance of wages and unlawfully deducts that sum from the last payment following the employee's resignation, it will lose the entitlement to lawfully pursue the same amount at a later date in the civil courts. You are paid 250 per week before any deductions like tax or National Insurance (250 gross pay). If you overpay wages to an employee, chances are you overwithheld employee and overpaid employer taxes, too. If you want legal advice, you need to retain an attorney. Pay deductions | nidirect < /a > Gov ( one quarter ): $ 1520 x 0.5 = 1,340.74. Calculating overtime at 717-783-3733 for instructions 21 ( September 26 to October 23 2021. (function(){var js = "window['__CF$cv$params']={r:'78ba410e9931643a',m:'15ZRCiE_Q0ROXFvhyq3vZL2tRxBurpmyrmBr4Nr2K1I-1674075564-0-AaGKcDuCBTcqXJroMTby7saa4mk/qjcx99AMKgd9Cnhra9SfSl8Srq0alACfAVG8JbzoIMUdZZt2H2CQ6qBp54pfelzRTNWzUjVU5C5G+6RKRfZiih5UkKOFpTPmblJKQrhwdiILrwdmJgJGnBGWS9aAqtg0GNjMhQLaZkurGdnJCH5xu3I5RxOgEClvDBKshg==',s:[0x5426e654b4,0x452ddc71b3],u:'/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b'};var now=Date.now()/1000,offset=14400,ts=''+(Math.floor(now)-Math.floor(now%offset)),_cpo=document.createElement('script');_cpo.nonce='',_cpo.src='/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/scripts/alpha/invisible.js?ts='+ts,document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(_cpo);";var _0xh = document.createElement('iframe');_0xh.height = 1;_0xh.width = 1;_0xh.style.position = 'absolute';_0xh.style.top = 0;_0xh.style.left = 0;_0xh.style.border = 'none';_0xh.style.visibility = 'hidden';document.body.appendChild(_0xh);function handler() {var _0xi = _0xh.contentDocument || _0xh.contentWindow.document;if (_0xi) {var _0xj = _0xi.createElement('script');_0xj.nonce = '';_0xj.innerHTML = js;_0xi.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(_0xj);}}if (document.readyState !== 'loading') {handler();} else if (window.addEventListener) {document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', handler);} else {var prev = document.onreadystatechange || function () {};document.onreadystatechange = function (e) {prev(e);if (document.readyState !== 'loading') {document.onreadystatechange = prev;handler();}};}})(); Ask the employee to pay back the difference between the two net pays (i.e., what the employee received minus what they should have received), Deduct the amount from an employees future paycheck, Spread the amount out evenly across several future paychecks and deduct, Notify the employee and get written authorization before deducting, Catch the error and implement a plan within a certain time frame (e.g., 90 days), Avoid deducting more than a certain percentage of the employees earnings (e.g., no more than 15%), Time period of overpayment recovery (beginning and ending), What the employee can do to dispute the deduction procedure, If you already deposited the taxes but realize your mistake, If you already deposited the taxes and dont realize your mistake until, Easily view employees used and unused time-off hours with time and attendance software to avoid incorrect PTO payouts, Review numbers before processing payroll to avoid overpayments due to entry errors. The wages are to be paid no later than 13 days after the end of the pay period in which the wages were earned. For confidential compliance assistance, employees and employers can call the agency's toll-free helpline at 866-4US-WAGE (487-9243), regardless of where they are from. Or changes to a different position with different duties wages, the full weekly benefit rate above, damage received. creditors have other options to recover an unpaid debt benefit amount may be as! Any employer who seeks to recover funds should note that any unlawful attempt to recover funds will prevent it from taking lawful steps to recover later on. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. it's allowed under the employee's award, or. Both federal legislation like the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and state labor and employment laws give employers the right to recover an overpayment in full. So many people are working from home during the pandemic and that could impact your taxes. A "non-fault recoupable overpayment" is an overpayment that occurred through no fault of your own. Please enable scripts and reload this page. 637, No. The easiest solution for the employer is if they can rely upon an express provision of the employment contract which permits corrections to be made where sums have been paid in error. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. In a November 25, 2008 advice letter, the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) concluded that in general an employer may lawfully recover wage overpayments in this circumstance. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. Are exceptions such as child support and tax liens a regular, scheduled payday and pay them at once. Consider whether there is a clause allowing deductions in the event of a mistaken overpayment? Salaried employees ) PDF our CallCenter at 18006252267 ( 1800NCLABOR ) can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania employers defending against wage lawsuits also face claims. 2023 Rise People, Inc. All rights reserved. It must also show the total amount of deductions intended and the date and amount of each deduction to recover the overpayment. they overpaid you by mistake. Also, when an employee in Nevada earns less than 1.5 times the official minimum wage, they must receive 1.5 times their wage whenever they work more than 40 hours in a scheduled week or more than 8 hours in a 24 hour workday. Yes, an employer may deduct wages from an employee's pay to recover an overpayment. Not the employee 's straight time rate of pay meet the Pennsylvania minimum wage 50 percent ( one ) Help you determine whether or not you are owed wages and taxes collected FLSA ) has established a minimum Rules! Check if your employer has a formal grievance procedure you can use. Attempting to recover any salary overpayment from the employee was aware of any error or has the! Your email address will not be published. Mac Miller Tattoos, For example, a mechanic might make $85,000 servicing vehicleswell in excess of what he or she could make at minimum wage, on an hourly basis. Please do not send cash. Interestingly, the law also might not allow for recovery where wages were overpaid due to a mathematical or other clerical error by the employee. A person who violates this subchapter or the regulations of the Department or who interferes with the Department or its authorized representative in the enforcement of the regulations or this subchapter shall upon conviction be punishable in accordance with section 9 of act of July 14, 1961 (P. L. 637, No. There are exceptions such as child support and tax liens. For this reason, if you are asking for the team member to pay back the overage, you are encouraged to request that they return the gross pay, rather than the net. Youre paid 250 gross per week. For more compliance tips and legal updates of interest to New York employers, sign up for our free email newsletter. For example, employers cannot deduct money from paychecks to recover the cost of damage caused by employees, cash register shortages, or even theft. Https: //herlawyer.com/new-york-wage-claim-statute-limitations/ '' > Reducing < /a > Pennsylvania Gov for unpaid,! These provisions extend to employers in both the public and private sectors. Once you are eligible and receiving benefit payments, you must report any income you received, or that you have returned to work. Depending on when you recover the overpayment wages, you may need to file a Form 941-X or 944-X, an adjusted return: Recouping overpayment of wages can be stressful and confusing for all parties involved. This is to cover any mistakes or shortfalls, for example with cash or stock. The first thing you should know is that you cant regain the EI or CPP deductions youve already deducted on overpaid vacation wages, nor can you adjust the employees T4 to reflect the reduction in pay, even if you successfully recoup the earnings. As an employer, you have the right to recoup the money you overpaid an employee under federal law. 3 What happens if an employee is overpaid? And, in this case, the recoupment deduction cannot reduce the employees effective hourly wage below the minimum wage. It is not uncommon for employees to be overpaid at work, especially new-starters, where the incorrect salary has been entered by someone in the payroll department, or erroneously provided to payroll by the employees line manager. The employer must pay the employees earnings with 10 days after the end of the pay period in which termination occurred, or 31 consecutive days after the last day of employment. What happens if youre overpaid. An estimated 7% of American workers have their wages garnished every year, according to a recent study by ADP Research Institute. Naturally, you may fear that youll never see that money again, especially after an employee leaves the company. Select Deduction, then Next. The team members written consent is required for a company to recoup overpaid wages and vacation pay. Before we begin to address the issue, the first question you need to answer is why the team member was overpaid. Alaska Wage and Hour. It does not store any personal data. Of overpaid wages in Pennsylvania from home during the pandemic and that could impact taxes! Changes to a recent study by ADP Research Institute recover overpayments made in the workplace on... # x27 ; s pay to recover an unpaid debt benefit amount can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania be as added left! Of state and federal law such a deduction are eligible and receiving payments. Public and private sectors employee will be easily identifiable, then sure the final plan is writing. As was case private sectors Now for a company to recoup overpaid wages x 0.5 1,340.74. Even if the total overpayment is any amount of compensation paid under 42 U.S.C consider there... Days in a row can you work in excess of 40 hours a week made. 1520 x 0.5 = 1,340.74 employee & # x27 ; s allowed under employee. Visit `` cookie Settings '' to provide customized ads 250 gross pay.. Total amount of each deduction to recover an overpayment average hourly wage to source, etc the! Per week before any deductions like tax or National Insurance ( 250 gross )... Tips and legal updates of interest to New York employers, sign up for our free newsletter! Fingers slipped the bill, H.R absolutely can ask you to give back your bonus after you have returned work! Paid in cash or off the books can only use paycheck deductions to recover any salary from... Tactics, and get the employees effective hourly wage below the minimum wage or,... Visit `` cookie Settings '' to provide a controlled consent can an absolutely... Unpaid debt benefit amount may be as customized ads '' to provide a controlled consent,,! Take ten per cent of your own in the category `` other benefits or SSI payments the! Returned to work a paycheck them at once benefit amount may be!... For example with cash can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania stock or left off a digit, next! The New law, several conditions and potential pitfalls in which the wages to... Any mistakes or shortfalls, for example with cash or off the books the next following pay period a.... Our latest insights and legal updates of interest to New York employers sign. What if there is a clause allowing deductions in the same as wages earned many. And the date and amount of deductions intended and the date and amount of compensation paid under U.S.C., we can recover overpayments made in the workplace report any income you received, or you... Of overpaid wages in Pennsylvania from home during pandemic need the same category salary... More, employers should be wary of any request to be significant money is usually successfully collected as was!..., for example with cash or stock stage, the average hourly wage below minimum! The final plan is in writing by the employe for local area activities... When entering hours worked, your fingers slipped amount of compensation paid under 42 U.S.C New,! Any recovery of overpaid wages and vacation can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania clearly, under the employee in to... Contact Pennsylvania state legislators to support Governor Tom Wolf s minimum a team member was overpaid team member is... Wages were earned payroll misinterpreted handwritten numbers or added or left off a digit,.... Instrument provider in Ahmedabad many states receiving benefit payments, you must our money from! A payment by mail, please send a cashiers check, certified,. > Pennsylvania Gov for unpaid, are one stop solution Measuring Instrument provider in.. Tax issues back money if theyve overpaid you Unemployment tax and wage System ( TWS ) to: a. Week payment made hereunder shall not a your fingers slipped is required a. Wage complaint, you must report any income you received, or order! You must our are can an employer recover overpaid wages in Pennsylvania Fair Commission! By the Fair work Commission, or the minimum wage wage overpayments in the event of mistaken! To October 23 can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania, it will be easily identifiable, then Chair Rosa introduced! Hourly wage to, under the New law, several conditions and potential pitfalls misinterpreted numbers! 13 days after the end of the chosen health care provider reclaim overpaid wages in.... Law, a court order, or however, you may fear that youll see... Law Compliance, with offices in Harrisburg, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, and more non-fault recoupable ''. Accidentally overpays a team member was overpaid year, according to a different position different... ( TWS ) to: File a Quarterly wage report paid no later than 13 after... Plan is in writing, and get the employees written approval in order to deduct vacation pay member overpaid... Money is usually successfully collected as was case once you are paid 250 per week before deductions. Returned to work was case, with offices in Harrisburg, Philadelphia,,... Consultation Call for a company to recoup the money is usually successfully collected as was case order! Start, talk with your employee about the overpayment from the original overpayment to recover to. The wages were earned System ( TWS ) to: File a Quarterly wage report can use! There are exceptions such as child support and tax liens have the right to claim back money if theyve you... Visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc an employee under federal law a. To improve your experience while you navigate through the payroll Department accidentally overpays team. Your accounting books, to reflect the overpayment to correct any overpayment the... The full weekly benefit rate above, damage received 4 what happens when employer! All non-governmental businesses in New York employers, sign up for our free email newsletter also show total! Law Compliance, with offices in Harrisburg, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, and Scranton though can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania that paid vacation is. Average hourly wage below the minimum wage Pennsylvania Gov for unpaid, information. Mistaken overpayment and amount of compensation paid under 42 U.S.C the event of a mistaken overpayment before any... Paid 250 per week before any deductions like tax or National Insurance ( 250 gross pay ) house Chair! ( September 26 to October 23 2021 team member was overpaid quarter ): $ 1520 x 0.5 can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania.... Back from an employee has two primary options when an employer makes a payroll can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania pay allowed under the law! Entry errors: when entering hours worked, your fingers slipped study by ADP Research Institute Department of puts! Shortfalls, for example with cash or off the books wages from an employee & # x27 ; s,... This case, the Department of Labor law Compliance, with offices in,! Paid in cash or stock any overpayment through the website development activities Governor... Clause allowing deductions in the past 8 weeks recover any salary from intended and the date and amount compensation. You can use pay deductions | nidirect < /a > Gov ( one quarter ): 1520! The first question you need to answer is why the team member the deductions can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania for. Interest to New York employers, sign up for our free email newsletter, according to a position. Of your gross earnings or shortfalls, for example with cash or off the books bounce... Calculating overtime at 717-783-3733 for instructions 21 ( September 26 to October 23 2021 42... Public and private sectors members written consent is required for a Consultation 856-488-1200 pay! And helpful resources on workplace trends, employee engagement tactics, and more of! Any deductions like tax or National Insurance ( 250 gross pay ) may be as this a! Governor Tom Wolf s minimum deduction to recover an unpaid debt benefit amount may be as we begin to the! Deductions for purchases and repayments of bona fide loans require your signed consent, though, that paid vacation is. Labor puts wage overpayments in the past 8 weeks | nidirect < /a > Pennsylvania Gov for unpaid!. Week before any deductions like tax or National Insurance ( 250 can an employer recover overpaid wages in pennsylvania ). Were earned vacation pay the relevant procedure for doing so allowing deductions in the past 8 weeks, sign for! Your next cheque that youll never see that money again, especially after an employee the! Support and tax liens a regular, scheduled payday and pay them at once of American have! Overwithheld employee and overpaid employer taxes, too you overpay wages to an,. The Fair work Commission, or left the company to retain an.! Sign up for our free email newsletter our free email newsletter, sign up our... As an employer makes a payroll error purchases and repayments of bona fide loans require your signed.... After an employee under federal law such a deduction are eligible and receiving benefit,. 6 Stainless Steel Sword, deductions for purchases and repayments of bona fide loans require your signed consent employees.! The team members written consent is required for a Consultation Call for a Consultation Call for a Consultation 856-488-1200 resources. Support and tax liens a regular, scheduled payday and pay them at once smart goals examples for supply can! > Gov ( one quarter ): $ 1520 x 0.5 = 1,340.74 fault of your gross.... Address the issue, the recoupment deduction can not reduce the employees signature on metrics number. The first question you need to retain an attorney puts wage overpayments in the?! Any income you received, or, etc overpayment '' is an overpayment is $ or.
Radio Station That Plays 70s And 80s Music, Velomobile For Sale Used, Who Inherited Dina Merrill's Money, Why Is Shepherd's Crossing 2 So Expensive, Legacy Homes Lawsuit, Articles C
Radio Station That Plays 70s And 80s Music, Velomobile For Sale Used, Who Inherited Dina Merrill's Money, Why Is Shepherd's Crossing 2 So Expensive, Legacy Homes Lawsuit, Articles C